When Elevators Let You Down

Frank Campise
Campise Consulting & Inspections
Ep.
105

When Elevators Let You Down: The High Cost of Going Up

Elevators are one of the most expensive systems a high-rise association is responsible for maintaining, and among the most consequential when they stop working. Residents may never think about the equipment that moves them between floors until they find themselves waiting ten minutes for a car, climbing several flights of stairs, or dealing with another unexpected shutdown. For HOA boards, persistent elevator problems can be particularly frustrating because the financial investment in maintenance doesn't always seem to translate into reliable service.

On this episode of The Uncommon Area, Matthew Holbrook speaks with Frank Campise of Campise Consulting & Inspections about what boards should understand before making decisions about elevator maintenance, reserve funding, and modernization. With more than 30 years of experience in the elevator industry, Frank offers a perspective that challenges some common assumptions about how long elevators should last, who should maintain them, and when replacement is actually necessary.

What are you really getting from your maintenance contract?

One of the more revealing parts of the conversation concerns the way elevator maintenance agreements are written. Many boards assume that paying for a full-service contract means their equipment is receiving sufficient preventative maintenance. According to Frank, however, the contracts often leave the frequency and duration of that maintenance largely to the service provider's discretion.

Agreements may call for "systematic" or "periodic" maintenance without specifying how many hours a technician must actually spend servicing the equipment. That leaves boards with little ability to measure whether the work they're paying for is being performed consistently. When an elevator breaks down, the company sends a technician to get it running again, but those service calls shouldn't be confused with the preventative work intended to avoid the breakdown in the first place.

Frank recommends contracts that establish specific preventative maintenance hours based on the number of elevators in the building, with callback service tracked separately. He has seen a clear relationship between requiring those hours and reducing the frequency of breakdowns. It's a practical example of how a relatively straightforward change to a service agreement can improve reliability without requiring an expensive equipment upgrade.

The conversation also addresses whether associations are obligated to use the company that manufactured their elevators. While certain proprietary systems can limit an owner's options, Frank explains that many elevators can be maintained by other qualified providers. The challenge is finding a company with the appropriate experience and reviewing the existing contract before attempting to make a change. He cautions that maintenance agreements written by service providers can contain terms that make termination difficult, leaving boards with fewer options than they may realize.

Why elevators aren't lasting as long as expected

When planning for major capital expenses, boards generally rely on expected useful lives to determine how much money should be set aside in reserves. But elevator modernization is becoming harder to predict because the longevity of the equipment doesn't always match the availability of its replacement parts.

Frank explains that the electronic controller, essentially the brain of the elevator, is often one of the first major components to require modernization. Although he generally uses a useful life of approximately 20 to 25 years in his reports, he has seen manufacturers discontinue support for electronic boards and drives in considerably less time, sometimes after just 10 to 15 years.

This creates an unusual situation in which equipment may remain mechanically sound but become difficult or impossible to repair because a particular electronic component is no longer available. Frank contrasts this with older elevators that have remained in service for decades because their mechanical components can still be repaired. He also describes how some newer machine-room-less elevator systems contain machinery that is replaced rather than repaired when it fails.

For boards, these developments complicate reserve planning. A building may have elevators that are relatively young and otherwise well maintained, yet still face a significant modernization expense earlier than anticipated. Understanding which components are installed, whether replacement parts remain available, and what manufacturers are continuing to support can help associations make more realistic projections.

The modernization costs that reserve studies may miss

Elevators are frequently among the largest components in a high-rise reserve study, so even a modest error in their projected replacement costs can have significant consequences. Frank cautions against relying exclusively on estimates provided by elevator maintenance companies because those estimates may cover only the contractor's direct scope of work.

A modernization project can trigger additional electrical and life safety work that falls outside the elevator company's proposal. These expenses, which Frank refers to as "work by others," need to be included in the association's overall budget. Without them, boards can find themselves facing costs that weren't accounted for when reserve contributions were established.

Frank recommends obtaining an independent evaluation to establish both a realistic project budget and an appropriate replacement timeline. Rather than assuming that all elevators of a certain age need modernization, an evaluation can identify which components remain serviceable and which are approaching the end of their useful lives. He suggests that associations begin paying closer attention to equipment condition around the 15-year mark, particularly if shutdowns are becoming more frequent or replacement parts are increasingly difficult to obtain.

That information gives boards a better foundation for determining when to undertake a major project and whether their existing reserves will be sufficient.

What boards should expect from a modernization project

One of the biggest surprises for boards may be how long an elevator modernization actually takes. Frank explains that from the time an association decides to move forward, it can take approximately six months before equipment is ready for installation. That period includes assessing the existing elevators, developing project specifications, soliciting bids, selecting a contractor, and manufacturing the necessary equipment.

Installation adds another substantial period of disruption. For a residential elevator serving approximately 20 floors, Frank estimates an installation time of 18 to 20 weeks. A building with four elevators could be looking at a total modernization project lasting 12 to 14 months.

Because residential buildings need to maintain elevator service throughout construction, the work is generally completed one elevator at a time. This means residents may spend months with fewer elevators available, and the remaining equipment must continue operating while the project is underway. Frank notes that wait times can increase considerably during modernization, potentially reaching five to ten minutes depending on the building and number of residents.

These conditions make the planning process especially important. Frank recommends developing clear project specifications before going out to bid so contractors are pricing comparable work. He also encourages boards to consider which features they want to incorporate into the modernization, such as improved access controls or floor-position indicators, and to evaluate opportunities to reduce the period when individual elevators must be taken completely out of service.

The discussion makes clear why waiting until equipment is experiencing severe problems can put boards in a difficult position. A modernization project already requires considerable preparation and patience from residents. Beginning that process while the remaining elevators are struggling to operate reliably only adds to the disruption.

Understanding elevator safety

The episode also addresses some of the fears surrounding elevator safety, including the familiar movie scenario of a cable snapping and an elevator plummeting down the shaft. Frank explains that traction elevators use multiple cables with substantial load-bearing capacity, and modern elevator systems incorporate redundant safety mechanisms.

Entrapments are a more realistic concern for residential buildings, although Frank emphasizes that remaining inside the elevator and requesting professional assistance is generally the safest response. He also stresses the importance of keeping emergency communication systems operational, since a trapped passenger may not have a working cell phone.

Response times can vary depending on when an entrapment occurs and where a technician is located. Frank notes that after-hours service can take longer because fewer technicians are available, reinforcing the importance of established emergency procedures and reliable communication equipment.

Planning ahead for better reliability

Throughout the conversation, Frank returns to the importance of understanding the equipment and making informed decisions before a major failure forces the issue. A well-written maintenance agreement can establish better accountability, while an independent equipment assessment can help boards distinguish between problems that require repairs and those that justify modernization.

The financial implications are substantial, but the effect on residents is just as important. In a high-rise community, elevator reliability directly affects how people experience their homes. Boards that establish realistic maintenance expectations and plan early for major capital improvements are in a much stronger position to protect that experience.

Watch the full episode of The Uncommon Area above for Matthew Holbrook's conversation with Frank Campise, including their discussion of elevator maintenance contracts, modernization timelines, and safety.

Learn more about Frank's work at Campise Consulting & Inspections.

Tell Us About Your Community.
We’ll Handle the Rest.

get a custom proposal